Professor Greg Pawloski, current faculty/staff colleague: Marshak had a profound impact on the field of experimental particle physics. He helped pioneer the development of the first proton decay experiment in the Soundan Iron Mine in Northern Minnesota and was instrumental in establishing the lineage of Minnesota-based neutrino experiments which culminated in the MINOS and NOvA experiments. Marshak supervised the construction and operation of the NOvA Ash River Laboratory, including the installation of the 14,000 ton NOvA Far Detector in Ash River, MN. Marshak had a tremendous influence on numerous people in the field of neutrino physics, with many beginning their research careers in one of these Minnesota-based experiments, benefiting directly from the foundation he helped build. In the earliest stages of DUNE, Marvin’s knowledge and expertise in developing large-scale detectors, hosted at remote labs, was a welcomed asset to the DUNE project. His influence will endure through the DUNE collaboration.
Aaron McGowan, Former Student (Graduate/Doctoral): Marvin trounced me on the racquetball court! I was preparing my dissertation in 2006 and he invited me to a friendly match in the Rec Center on campus.
I was in the prime of my youth, spry, a little cocky, eager to best my mentor in a display of physical prowess. Precious few points went my way, and no games. Marvin’s years of experience on the court made it too easy for him to send me dashing from corner to corner, often coming up short of reaching an expertly placed shot. In hindsight, I should have known such a seasoned physicist would have all the best angles stored in muscle memory and could ricochet as many walls as needed to keep me guessing. He had no trouble thoroughly dispatching a physicist less than half his age.
As a Ph.D. advisor, Marvin struck a delicate balance between passively observing my progress and actively intervening when I needed guidance. After having taught physics myself for 18 years and mentoring a dozen research students, I now appreciate how difficult this balance is to achieve. Marvin knew how to allow me space to struggle and find my limitations, which is a key ingredient in learning at all stages of life. He also knew how to redirect me if I was getting lost on a tangent or fixating on second-order effects when I had not sufficiently addressed first-order effects.
My access to multiple generations of neutrino detectors was arranged by Marvin. He involved me in the careful de-commissioning of Soudan-2, which was constructed when I was in grade school. He helped me to get my hands on the MINOS Far Detector hardware and learn the ropes at the local control room. After I completed my coursework at UMN, Marvin arranged for me to work under Maury Goodman, my dissertation co-advisor, at Argonne. I found an apartment halfway between FNAL and ANL, and he pushed me to cut my teeth on weeks worth of night shifts in the MINOS remote control station in Wilson Hall. I look back on those shifts fondly. I am looking up at a poster with a few MINOS event displays that Marvin taught me to interpret: neutrino beam-induced contained-vertex interactions versus rock-vertex interactions that sent a muon into the detector.
Marvin pushed on some boundaries within the confines of multi-national neutrino collaborations. He was not a fan of some forms of blind analysis. He was driven by his curiosity to ask nature to whisper the answer in his ear before any official analysis results were blessed. I look back fondly on our hand-scanning sessions with Tony, and his unofficial (controversial) spreadsheet plots of energy distributions.
Rik Gran, former student (Graduate/Doctoral): I’ve known Marvin since just before starting my Ph.D. program in 1994. This was toward the end of his time as Physics Department Head. For me he was using some random fund related to an outreach event to hire me and give me a research project the summer before starting my doctoral studies. I don’t know if the FORTRAN code was his or some other student’s, but it encouraged me to switch to C++ as soon as possible. But I stayed on the Soudan2 experiment for my whole Ph.D.
Of course, Marvin has been an outstanding mentor throughout my career. I’ve been in Minnesota and associated with the Soudan Lab and neutrino physics for most of my career. Marvin and I had many conversations on many topics, the two of us, sometimes trapped in a car or in the mine, or in small and large groups of all types. The thing that stands out to me isn’t one of those conversations in particular (maybe one). Instead, one of Marvin’s object lessons on the practice of leadership (and also the practicality of working at Soudan and in Northern Minnesota) was personally taking on a real share of the un-glamorous work. I’m pretty sure it was because he found enjoyment in it for its own sake (but not always), or a kind of refuge, in addition to the benefits it brought to the team and the enterprise. A few years ago I recognized an accumulation of leadership success from people who were associated with the Soudan Lab as students, postdocs, or junior faculty. There are now many (countless?) university department heads, seven (?) collaboration spokespersons or deputies, and the current Director General of CERN. I’m sure we had this in us from the beginning, but Marvin showed us (and/or created the conditions for us to learn) how take on these roles, what were the right reasons, and why it was important that we do them.
John LoSecco, current faculty/staff colleague: Marvin and I have only collaborated in the recent DUNE experiment. Earlier in our careers we worked on "competing" projects. One of my first useful interactions with Marvin was to help him publicize a rather dramatic discovery. We have been friends ever since. Marvin has always been professional and practical, an ideal competitor.
Niki Saoulidou, current faculty/staff colleague: I will always remember Marvin as the Senior and experienced MINOS Colleague that was almost more eager than us, young postdocs back then, to visually scan each and every beam neutrino event we recorded with the MINOS Far Detector! Marvin was full of enthusiasm, a force of nature in everything he did, and a true inspiration for younger physicists! I will miss you Marvin, and I thank you for the kindness and support with which you have always treated me. Farewell, Niki Saoulidou
Tim Bolton, current faculty/staff colleague: I first met Marvin in summer of 1981. Marvin, ever the innovator, has set up an early version of an NSF REU program with 12 undergraduates from across the country. It was an eventful summer. A tornado smashed up our group house a few days before we arrived. And Minnesota state employees went on strike for the summer, ostensibly preventing us from visiting the Soudan 1 proton decay (at the time!) experiment. Ever the optimist, Marvin still put together a great program. And in spite of the strike, we somehow managed to get underground in Soudan. Marvin could get things done! I owe my career in high energy physics to my experience that summer with him.
I next saw him many years later in 2013 while working for the DOE on a visit to Minnesota. We enjoyed a memorable road trip to Soudan and then Ash River to tour the MINOS and Nova detectors. Not surprisingly, Marvin brought along a couple of UMn undergrads for the tour. A highlight was meeting Bill Miller, the maestro of underground physics experiments, for the first time. Bill is an example of Marvin's ability to pick out and nurture talent from any and all sources.
A few years later when I became involved in DUNE management, Marvin made a huge impact on DUNE far detector development and the ProtoDUNE experiments by bringing Bill Miller into the project and facilitating the use of Ash River as a DUNE detector test facility.
Marvin must rank as one of the greatest physics entrepreneurs of all time. He was fun and exciting to be around, incredibly positive, and above all, a kind and caring man.
Alec Habig, current faculty/staff colleague: In our field, our lives are traditionally formed by our PhD and postdoctoral advisors. However, I was also lucky enough to start working with Marvin as a new Asst. Professor. Although not even on his campus, Marvin went out of his way to guide me through how Professor-ing was done, how to run laboratories, and how to work with students. I owe a great deal to Marvin's kind and wise mentorship, and will miss him a lot.
Heidi Schellman, Former Faculty/Staff Colleague: I first met Marvin when he came to Northwestern to give the colloquium - which was on physics and finance. I ran into him in the hallway after he had been talking to some of my more irascible colleagues. His first words were " I made two mistakes today, taking the El from Midway to Evanston and arguing with [redacted]" He then went on to give a very clear talk about how physics relates to finance and optimal portfolio theory is largely the central limit theorem. I was sufficiently inspired by his explanation that I started saving more and avoided individual stocks. 30 years later, I think I earned about $1M from that colloquium.
Name of redacted available upon request.